I would like to begin this post with a disclaimer. I love
Modern Family. I think it is funny and quirky and tells some great stories, and I’m pretty sure my husband is going to give himself a hernia one of these days laughing at Phil Dunphy.
If you don’t know the premise of the show, here’s a quick breakdown. Jay Pritchett is the patriarch. He is married to the much younger and Columbian Gloria. Gloria’s son lives with them and they recently had a baby of their own. Jay has two children, Claire and Mitch. Claire is a SAHM married to Phil, a real estate agent. They have three children. Mitch is in a relationship with Cam, a SAHD, and they have adopted a daughter from Vietnam.
Presumably the name
Modern Family came from the fact that one of the families was a headed by a gay couple and the other by a May-December romance. Beyond that, there’s not much “modern” going on.
Each family has a working spouse in a traditional job and a stay at home spouse who takes care of the home and children full time. The twist is that one of the couples is gay, so the stay at home spouse is not a woman. However, Cam is generally played as the more traditionally “wife-like” member of the couple. He loves crafts and decorating and party planning and costumes and show tunes. He tried to “work” for a couple of episodes and just couldn’t stand to be away from his daughter for that long. Claire gave up her career when her children were born and is now struggling with her identity and the possibility of moving back into the workforce. This is something that many women struggle with, but many modern families have two working spouses. How about a family with young children where both parents work and they manage to keep their house running smoothly. Now
that would be groundbreaking television.
The other edgy “modern” couple is Jay and Gloria. Jay is divorced from Claire and Mitch’s mother, who makes and occasional appearance on the show. Much fun is made of Gloria’s hotness and how fortunate Jay is to be with her. His libido is never played for jokes against him. It is seen as totally normal, which, presumably it is. He and Gloria seem sincerely in love. However, whenever Jay’s ex-wife appears on the scene, her attraction to younger men is seen as a pathetic joke. She is played as manipulative and passive aggressive and her presumably excessive sex drive is an off shoot of her personality disorders.
While I understand the need for traditional family story lines, the fact that this show purports to be about a modern family (by stating it explicitly in the title) is disappointing, as it’s obvious the producers and writers just took a traditional Ozzie and Harriet family and gave it a little gay twist and called it a day. One would hope for more creativity, but that's often not the case.